COLLAGENETICS 2 IN 1 LOTION
“Collagenetics 2 in 1 delivers excellent moisturizing and effective red light therapy results at a fraction of salon pricing, though its tanning-boost effect is inconsistent for some.”
Safety — Flagged for Review
Recurring pattern2 independent reports of burning on skin during use. One reviewer states 'Both times using it burned me'; another states 'Both times I used it I burned in one area.' Additionally, 2 reports of unusual tingling/prickling sensation described as 'like pop rocks' and 'tingly sensation', though sensation reportedly subsided. This does not yet indicate a systemic issue — only 2 explicit burning reports across 147 reviews — but the consistency of the complaint (both occurring on repeat use) warrants investigation into whether specific ingredient concentrations or interactions trigger localized irritation in a subset of users.
Negative reviews span Mar 2018–Jul 2025
Authenticity — Marketplace Concern
Recurring pattern4 independent reports of unsealed, tampered, or suspected counterfeit units: missing or broken security seals, lotion already present in cap at arrival, wrong label fit on bottle, and one explicit 'I'm almost 100 percent sure it is a fake' claim. This is a marketplace/supply-chain integrity issue — either FBA commingling, supplier fraud, or fulfillment error — not a formula defect. Requires verification that inventory stock is authentic and fulfillment process prevents resale of returned/opened units.
Negative reviews span Mar 2018–Jul 2025
Based on unverified customer accounts in Amazon review text, not confirmed medical or lab findings.
Avg Rating
4.31★
147 reviews
Positive
80.3%
Rated 4★ or 5★
Neutral
10.2%
Rated 3★
Negative
9.5%
Rated 1★ or 2★
Sentiment Score
78/100
positive
What Customers Love
Excellent moisturizing and skin-softening properties
“This is my third bottle of this and it really helps the red light therapy do it's thing on my skin it's just like so silky soft now.”
Works effectively for red light therapy sessions
“Red light therapy itself repairs skin but when used in combination with this cream, the results are sustained and amazing.”
Convenient 2-in-1 formula saves time and money vs. salon pricing
“You would easily pay double the cost at a tanning salon.”
Pleasant, non-typical tanning lotion fragrance
“When I apply this lotion, I honestly smell like I'm wearing an elevated, clean, fruity-floral perfume, even after I get out.”
Customer Feedback
AI summary. Numbers in it are the model’s estimates; counted figures are in Issue evidence below.
Bottles arriving unsealed, used, or tampered with — multiple independent reports of missing inner seals and lotion in the cap
Authenticity“The silver tab sealing the Product was already removed and lotion was in the cap.”
Tanning efficacy inconsistent — some users report minimal or no color development despite advertising as tanning accelerator
Product Failure“Didn't work for the tanning part . I got more color tanning with nothing than this.”
Burning and skin irritation on repeated use in specific body areas
Safety“Both times I used it I burned in one area.”
Unpleasant odor — customers describe it as 'Fritos-like' and overpowering
Experience“it stinks like Fritos and I'm still white so no good”
Sticky, gooey texture and difficult to rub in completely, leaving streaks and uneven color
Experience“I really don't care for it too much because of the way it makes my skin feel sticky and gooey. as soon as I put it on I want to take it off.”
Issue evidence
How these are countedCounted from this product’s 147 reviews with fixed keyword rules. Click a count to read the reviews.
Complaints (1–3★ reviews)
- Skin reactions42.7%Recurring
- Authenticity concerns42.7%Recurring
- Fragrance complaints32%Recurring
- Product effectiveness32%Recurring
- Packaging / dispenser10.7%Isolated
Praise (4–5★ reviews)
- Scent customers love2919.7%Recurring
- Moisturizing / skin feel2013.6%Recurring
- Cheaper than the salon32%Recurring
- Fast, dark results10.7%Isolated
% is the share of all 147 reviews. Recurring means 3+ reviews across 2+ different months. Listing: ASIN B00CSM4O00
Action Items by Team
Formulation & Safety (1)
- MEDIUMAdd a 'patch test recommended' warning and ingredient list to the Amazon listing imagery — 4 total mentions of burning or tingling/prickling sensations.
Brand Protection & Authenticity (1)
- HIGHAdd a close-up photo of an intact batch code and security seal to the Amazon listing so customers can verify authenticity on delivery.
Listing Content & SEO (3)
- HIGHRevise the listing title and bullets to clarify this is a red-light-therapy enhancer with light tanning boost, not a standalone dark-tanning accelerator.
- MEDIUMAdd application guidance to the listing: 'Massage in for 1-2 minutes for even coverage' — multiple reviews report a sticky, gooey texture that's hard to rub in.
- LOWAdd 'floral, herbal fragrance' to the listing description so customers can self-select — some 1-2-star reviews find the scent unpleasant ('Fritos-like').
Review Themes
Red light therapy hero, Excellent moisturizer, Tanning claims overblown, Unsealed/counterfeit units, Sticky texture complaint, Fragrance polarizing, Burning/irritation reports, Strong value vs. salons
All Reviews
All 147 Amazon reviews for this product are shown here for review · filter by star rating below
Showing 100 of 147 reviews · 5★ only — tap another rating below to switch
Smells great and increases tan!
This really ups the tanning game. Noticed a significant difference quickly, I will buy again. Doesn’t leave brown stains between fingers and smells great,
— Jessica Holbrook
The best hybrid lotion i have found.
I have only used it once since it arrived but I love it! It's thick and I don't have to use as much as other brands. It smells great, even after . It doe not leave a heavy greasy feeling. Very happy with this hybrid lotion for my hybrid bed. Will definitely purchase again.
— shanna brown
Beautiful fragrance
This smells surprisingly lovely! I saw other reviews saying that this lotion has a floral fragrance, which I thought would be a nice change of pace from all the usual tanning salon gourmands (coconut, sugar, vanilla, etc), especially since it’s springtime now. When I apply this lotion, I honestly smell like I’m wearing an elevated, clean, fruity-floral perfume, even after I get out of the tanning bed. If I could find a perfume that smelled like this, I would buy it! I decided I don’t want/need a barrier on my skin during red light sessions, but I will definitely keep using this for actual tanning. Plus I love the Y2K look of the packaging 🥰🙏🏼
— DocCasualty