Issues & Opportunities

Authenticity concerns

Medium

74 1–⁠3★ reviews (5.8% of 1,269) across 22 Devoted products, recurring on 10. 26 of them are from the last 24 months of data.

How a review gets counted

Customer says the product is fake, counterfeit, tampered, used, expired, watered down, or different from the salon version.

Example triggers: “fake”, “counterfeit”, “not authentic”, “watered down”, “used bottle”, “expired”. Only 1–⁠3★reviews are checked, and a match is skipped when a negation comes right before it (“no streaks”, “didn’t burn”). The highlighted phrase in each review below is what triggered it. Full methodology

Recommended action

File Amazon Brand Registry reports on the affected listings and ask the linked reviewers for batch codes, so you can tell counterfeit stock apart from a real batch problem.

Owner: Brand Protection & Authenticity

By product

ProductReviews% of product’s reviewsMonths seenFirst – latestPattern
Famous Faces15 of 2456.1%12Sep 2014 – Apr 2026Recurring
Black Obsession10 of 1317.6%9May 2019 – Apr 2026Recurring
Somewhere On A Beach8 of 3352.4%7Nov 2018 – Jul 2023Recurring
Dark Af6 of 1454.1%6Oct 2023 – Mar 2026Recurring
White 2 Bronze Pomegranate5 of 1573.2%5Oct 2018 – Jul 2025Recurring
Collagenetics 2 In 1 Lotion4 of 1472.7%4Oct 2019 – Feb 2023Recurring
White 2 Bronze Tingle4 of 1942.1%4Dec 2019 – Aug 2022Recurring
Collagenetics Spa Restorative Moisturizer3 of 1302.3%3May 2022 – Sep 2025Recurring
Black Velvet3 of 2171.4%3Apr 2024 – Jul 2024Recurring
Vacay Vibes3 of 2291.3%3Jul 2023 – May 2025Recurring
Fortune2 of 355.7%2Mar 2021 – Jun 2025Isolated
Blonde Obsession2 of 1911%2Jul 2016 – Jul 2017Isolated
Coconut Color Cream1 of 147.1%1Apr 2024 – Apr 2024Isolated
White 2 Bronze Coastal1 of 254%1Nov 2023 – Nov 2023Isolated
Moroccan Midnight1 of 263.8%1Apr 2023 – Apr 2023Isolated
Him Hydrate1 of 382.6%1Jul 2019 – Jul 2019Isolated
Honey Gleam Cream1 of 412.4%1Aug 2024 – Aug 2024Isolated
White 2 Bronze Ink1 of 422.4%1Mar 2022 – Mar 2022Isolated
Neon Rose1 of 741.4%1May 2025 – May 2025Isolated
Collagenetics 2 In 1 Pro1 of 821.2%1Aug 2019 – Aug 2019Isolated
Prismatica1 of 871.1%1Sep 2024 – Sep 2024Isolated
Tattoo Stick1 of 1630.6%1May 2022 – May 2022Isolated

Every matching review

Grouped by product, newest first.

Famous Faces

15 reviews · 6.1% of its 245 · ASIN B00655WLIS

  • ★★★★★Apr 21, 2026Charles Myers

    Terrible. Arrived half empty and the oils and lotion have already separated. Just a waste!

  • ★★★★★May 2, 2025Bri

    Possibly tampered with???. Just got this today and it looks like it’s been tampered with or something is wrong with it. Hopefully it’s just a fluke.

  • ★★★★★Mar 21, 2025The Williams

    packaging was damaged. i love this product and have used it so i bought it and when it came i was very disappointed because the packaging looks tampered with on the top. i’d like a refund or sent one that is not damaged. the product itself is very good and i love it.

  • ★★★★★Feb 21, 2025seserina

    Terrible. IF I COULD GIVE THIS NEGATIVE STARS I ABSOLUTELY 10000 PERCENT WOULD. this is genuinely the worst thing ive ever seen ever. The package is CLEARLYYY tampered with. There is dirt and grime all around the stick parts. wouldnt be surprised if there was lice sticking to it as well. Who knows where this came from, because i sure dont. It smells and reeks of sunscreen, and if you would like to live a pleasent life, plea…

  • ★★★★★Feb 17, 2025Michael Davis

    Fake!. Don’t waste your money! This is not the real deal and not even a dupe. It’s a plain unscented lotion with a DC stick slapped on the tube.

  • ★★★★★Nov 25, 2024Melissa M

    Beware. I gave this product over a month to work and it never did. I then reread several comments of fake stickers on the tube. I checked mine and it was a sticker as well so it’s hard to say what I’ve been putting on my face. I will never purchase again.

  • ★★★★★Nov 1, 2024Christina McCoy

    Horrible reaction-Buyer beware!. This product gave me a horrible reaction all over my face. My dermatologist said it was a virus - the product was most likely expired. It took over 2 months to heal with multiple prescriptions from my dermatologist. Buyer beware!

  • ★★★★★May 15, 2024Kimberly Roberts

    Warning. There wasn’t even an attempt to hide the fact that this was 100% tampered with. Disappointing.

  • ★★★★★May 15, 2024Kimberly Roberts

    Warning. There wasn’t even an attempt to hide the fact that this was 100% tampered with. Disappointing.

  • ★★★★★Apr 15, 2024Kayla

    Not same product. What comes in the container is not the same product I went to a tanning salon that sold the same product and completely different texture and worked wouldn’t recommend I used 6 times and nothing just like watered down lotion I ended up getting my happy face by hempz

  • ★★★★★Feb 9, 2024Maria Tennant

    Returned - Nervous to Use it. Product looked off and was not sealed at the top. Film easily pealed off, which made me wonder about the authenticity of the product. Can’t speak for the contents inside the bottle as I was nervous to use it.

  • ★★★★★Oct 5, 2020Deborah Miller

    Fake Product. This product is fake. Bought this because I wanted to start indoor tanning. Long story short a friend told me never buy tanning lotions off of Amazon. I found a different retailer to buy tanning lotions and I bought this same one for comparison. The …

  • ★★★★★Jan 6, 2019Stormy

    Fake or Old?. I received with the bottle looking lopsided and the bottom of the bottle is protruding out making it so the bottle won't stand up. The product is either fake or old. I'm returning.

  • ★★★★★Jul 8, 2018Jennifer

    Doesn’t ship as pictured. Three stars for now because it was shipped without a lid, and the pump is bent. My immediate concern was that it was tampered with, and it’s not the actual product inside. I’ll try it to see if it works. If not I’ll be returning because of the way it was shipped.

  • ★★★★★Sep 16, 2014jay

    …ttle it's there own fault... I am a very honest and hard worker that just wanted a good face tanner and saw good reviews for this one and got screwed over.. I did return the lotion but honestly i really shouldnt have to and didnt want to until I knew it was a fake.. Also, what these sellers dont know is if buyers like my self worked at a salon so were no idiots we know what the smell is, the consistency ,density, firmness, viscosity, ect.... I honestly dont think I will ever buy a tanning lotion on the net again, you w…

Black Obsession

10 reviews · 7.6% of its 131 · ASIN B07JQWT1L4

  • ★★★★★Apr 11, 2026Zurcn714

    Is it real or fake?. Product arrived unsealed, with a damaged label and the bottle was almost empty. Not sure if this is the real or fake product.

  • ★★★★★Dec 26, 2025Cindy

    Old stock. Old stock

  • ★★★★★Aug 2, 2024Sarah Anne

    …lly well the night before! It's just not worth it! There are positives though...a little goes a long way! And like I said I do get really dark with this! I just think with so many different ones out there devoted creations can do better!! Everyone saying it's fake..I bought mine from my trusted salon and it still feels the same way all of you are describing! Leaves me very streaky if I apply just a little to much or if I continue to try and rub or buff it in better. I just have to leave it alone after applying a light …

  • ★★★★★Dec 29, 2023Lela Nordyke

    Fake & STINKS!!. I had the original from the salon and thought i'd skip the trip out of town to grab some more. NOT WORTH IT, it stinks so bad. Not even the same color and was even scared to put this on my skin. Returned immediately

  • ★★★★★Feb 28, 2023Alysha Capson

    Fake. Waste of money. Not authentic. Applies like sunscreen, doesn't make you darker.

  • ★★★★★Mar 22, 2021Lanie Patterson

    Fake. This is why you don’t buy tanning lotion off line and not a legit lotion site. I work in a tanning salon and people do it all the time and come back complaining!

  • ★★★★★Mar 13, 2020Mark Hinkle

    NOT REAL DONT BUY!. Not the real lotion the color was off smell was off the texture was off i compared it to a salon bottle and they just put some fake stuff in these bottles they should not be aloud to sell to people it was horrible broke me out and made me have orange spots!

  • ★★★★★Mar 6, 2020kristine

    DAMAGED packing. completley damaged package ordered 2 bottles and both are same 1 bottle didnt have shiny text as it should be!!!!!!!!!! so I thinking....is the product real or fake......

  • ★★★★★Nov 10, 2019Avary Blu

    NOT REAL DEVOTED CREATIONS. Fake product :(

  • ★★★★★May 30, 2019kelly ryan

    Don’t purchase. A fake!! And I had to pay to return !!

Somewhere On A Beach

8 reviews · 2.4% of its 335 · ASIN B01M296DQ3

  • ★★★★★Jul 10, 2023C.T.

    …ing a lotion is the only way to take my tan to the next level. The scent is fine….your typical tanning lotion smell. I applied it with a lotion mitt and not my bare hand to achieve the most even tan as possible. It has a bronzer in it which will give you some fake tan color. If you don’t use a hand mitt to apply your lotion, you will probably want to wash your hands after applying it so your hands won’t get stained. I don’t feel, however, like there is a lot of bronzer in it because it didn’t give me as much color as w…

  • ★★★★★Mar 3, 2022Sarah

    Half empty. This bottle had already been opened and a lot was missing from it. Do not recommend!

  • ★★★★★May 20, 2021seandillingham

    Not the same anymore. We get this all the time but this one something was wrong watered down color what it is normally was way off and had a bad smell. Looks like we will have to find a different product.

  • ★★★★★Apr 21, 2021KG

    Not authentic. Not sure if this is legit or not. Used it 3 times and each time I use it I'm itching so bad. Never had this reaction before

  • ★★★★★Mar 15, 2020Melissa Archer

    Works well, but NOT the real thing. I've used Somewhere on a Beach that I purchased from the tanning salon, then bought this and they are NOT the same lotion. This one is much thinner and has a slightly lighter color. I tried it for awhile and did not tan as quickly or as deeply with thi…

  • ★★★★★Mar 6, 2020Marissa M Sawyer

    …s. It has a coconut smell like it should, but after tanning it smells horrendous. I burned with this lotion which never happens with the others, and it dried my skin out terribly. I don’t believe this is an actual devoted creation lotion, sadly I think it’s a knockoff. I bought another bottle from the salon today and am much happier with it. Don’t waste your money trying to save money with this stuff.

  • ★★★★★Jan 14, 2019Kassidy Harris

    Pretty sure its fake. Used to work at a tanning salon, pretty sure product is fake.

  • ★★★★★Nov 6, 2018marie-claude simard

    Old stuff. It is expired since 2018-04 and it wasn't mentioned in the description

Dark Af

6 reviews · 4.1% of its 145 · ASIN B099H6HZ4Z

  • ★★★★★Mar 23, 2026Taira Singleton

    Was this used?!? Not sure…. Haven’t used this product yet. Debating on if I will. I received this product but there was no safety packaging. The bottle feels full but not sure. If I wanted something that was already used I would have paid less and asked for that.

  • ★★★★★Feb 17, 2026Melissa

    Not a full product. Bottle came half full

  • ★★★★★May 9, 2025Cards Fan 4

    Awful after tan odor. Package was not sealed which made me suspicious. Had an off scent, but I decided to give it a try. It had the worst after tan odor ever! Even after a shower, I could still smell the awful odor. Wondering if the product is authentic. I returned it and do not recommend.

  • ★★★★★Apr 15, 2025Heather Hovis

    Received Used Bottle. All of the lotions I have ever ordered have always come sealed and this one did not and looks used to me 😡

  • ★★★★★Jul 10, 2024Angela Scott

    Possible Tampering. The product I received had a slit cut in the plastic piece in the opening. Was this a case of refilling a bottle with something. Cut was clean.

  • ★★★★★Oct 28, 2023Nick

    Watered down. Extremely watered down it’s not thick like the one they sell at my tanning salon.

White 2 Bronze Pomegranate

5 reviews · 3.2% of its 157 · ASIN B01FMSUD9M

  • ★★★★★Jul 22, 2025LP

    SCAM. !!SCAM!! This product is FAKE! Got my first shipment with no top, ordered a replacement again no top. It came completely spilled in the packaging.

  • ★★★★★Apr 11, 2025Nattaly Franzen

    Skip this product. This is definitely a knock off. This lotion should have a violet hue to it however, it has a small violet ring, but the lotion is white. This will not get you dark complete garbage wish I could give

  • ★★★★★Sep 8, 2023Shawn M.

    Very poor package- unsure if it’s even genuine. Received bottle today. Have used product previously in the sun bed shop but the one I got today just looks like a cheap and nasty fake. Unsure it’s it even the genuine product. Disappointed

  • ★★★★★Mar 12, 2020Angela

    Dont buy. Didnt work fake

  • ★★★★★Oct 31, 2018J. Schelp

    FAKE! ZERO STARS!. This is FAKE! They try and seal it themselves on the outside but once open you can totally tell they have refilled the bottle. Product was all over the spout and gushing out the lid. RETURNED!

Collagenetics 2 In 1 Lotion

4 reviews · 2.7% of its 147 · ASIN B00CSM4O00

  • ★★★★★Feb 28, 2023Ashtyn Eisenhower

    Awful. I was so excited to use this and when it came in it was damaged and I’m almost 100 percent sure it is a fake. Waste of money!

  • ★★★★★Jan 3, 2023brandi

    Seems like it’s a knockoff. The label is all bubbled up and doesn’t seem to fit the actual bottle. I’m pretty sure it’s a knockoff product and I will be sending it back.

  • ★★★★★Oct 15, 2020Alison Jean

    This was not a new item. Opened and already used. Gross!. I have bought this product many times over the last four years from various outlets. I was disgusted to open this and find that it had already been opened as the inner seal was missing. Not only that but there was a random brown gunk at the opening o…

  • ★★★★★Oct 18, 2019Bryan and Larisa

    Do not buy in my opinion if you get dry skin red light/tanning.. Does not keep my skin hydrated. I’m thinking this may be a knock off. My other red light therapy lotion did a great job.

White 2 Bronze Tingle

4 reviews · 2.1% of its 194 · ASIN B01MG5XZEP

  • ★★★★★Aug 1, 2022Mary Curry

    Dissatisfaction. Not what I have tried in the past. Maybe this one was tampered with? I’ve bought this product from the salon directly and it worked great. This one not so much. Waste of money

  • ★★★★★Jul 11, 2022Lisa Kolick

    Not the real thing. Very disappointed. Just took product out of the packaging. Bottle was not sealed. I have used this lotion for years and this smell is completely different. I have put a small amount on my leg. If anyone knows tingles it should start to get red. I will …

  • ★★★★★Sep 3, 2020Unhappy Customer

    Click past this item. It's not genuine. This product is not genuine. It has ZERO tingle. Previously, I've purchased this product in a salon. Product tingled as it claimed. This item sold by this vendor is NOT GENUINE. Since I have no idea what is actually being portrayed as a legitimate product, I…

  • ★★★★★Dec 22, 2019Gabi Fazio

    …fully, the lady was super sweet and assured me that this was a normal response to the lotion, and that it would go away with some time. Thankfully, she was right, and it did. And now I have the gentle glow of a suntanned week on the beach in only one 7-minute fake & bake from hell. Hate to say it, but it might have been worth it. 😈😂🥵

Collagenetics Spa Restorative Moisturizer

3 reviews · 2.3% of its 130 · ASIN B07YRYTLRQ

  • ★★★★★Sep 27, 2025Sandra K. Richter

    Collagenetics Moisturizer. I have really dry skin so I don’t know if my review is a fair review or not. I did not like this lotion. It was to me runny and just seemed watered down. It did soften my skin but after awhile I was needing to apply again. It is lightweight which i like the heavier lotions they seem to last longer as for effectiveness. Was it work the price? No not for me. Was it effective again not for me.

  • ★★★★★May 8, 2024CourtyB

    Fake! Knock Off!. Don’t buy. This is not authentic. I have a bottle of the real stuff and this one doesn’t match. Look at the back of this bottle compared to the back on the ad. You can see they’re different.

  • ★★★★★May 1, 2022Ashley Barth

    Was used!!! Disgusting!!!!!!. Delivered already opened used and so gross!!!! It was a mess. Sending back won’t purchase again very disappointed.

Black Velvet

3 reviews · 1.4% of its 217 · ASIN B07YRZ18WC

  • ★★★★★Jul 13, 2024Roma

    Expiration date wiped off?. The product smells rancid. I thought the bottle was just damaged from shipping but upon second look I noticed the expiration logo was wiped off. I believe product is old and expired .

  • ★★★★★Jun 17, 2024Hayden Crawford

    EXPIRED! Turned my hands grey/green!. I have been using tanning beds for almost a year and have tried a variety of different brands, bronzer combinations, and methods for applications. I ordered this product and after the first time I used it, my hands came out looki…

  • ★★★★★Apr 17, 2024Erica Hollingsworth

    … turned me very oompa loompa orange. Then I saw some pictures online of online shop fakes vs salon versions on this exact lotion and while my bottle looked the exact same, the content of mine did not look the same as the salon version it looked similar to the fake in the pictures.

Vacay Vibes

3 reviews · 1.3% of its 229 · ASIN B09MG4B2XB

  • ★★★★★May 12, 2025Jessica S

    …at reviews... How? This lotion isn't good at all. It dried my skin out immediately! It has a very strong smell, which it not pleasant, and lingers for 8+ hours! Gross! No where on the bottle is any manufacturer's date... Which lets you know when the lotion is expired. I've used many DC lotions as I was the GM for a tanning company for 5 years. They were all good lotions. This one... Not at all.

  • ★★★★★Nov 29, 2024Melissa

    …s me look a touch bronze but it must have DHA or some other self tanner. When I switched back to my old cream I burned at the normal amount of time I'd been using with this cream. Clearly this is not an accelerator for an indoor tanning bed and is more like a fake self tanner. It would be cool if it had both but this is clearly not an accelerator

  • ★★★★★Jul 2, 2023Jacklyn Rae Dobbins

    Would’ve been great if it hadn’t been opened. Was already opened…dirty bottle…crusty on the inside of the cap…half gone. Won’t buy again

Fortune

2 reviews · 5.7% of its 35 · ASIN B07YNTMKH9

  • ★★★★★Jun 10, 2025Samantha ralston

    Fake. Did not work like the bottle I purchased from the actual salon so pretty sure this is fake

  • ★★★★★Mar 20, 2021sabrina brady

    ** WARNING BUYERS BEWARE******. This is not the real Product I compared it to the fortune in my tanning salon and it is significantly lighter and does not have the same effect!

Blonde Obsession

2 reviews · 1% of its 191 · ASIN B00CG2FA0K

  • ★★★★★Jul 5, 2017Christina Thompson

    Fake. Product is fake and peels!!

  • ★★★★★Jul 9, 2016Lainey's Mom

    One Star. I honestly do not think this was the real product.. I think it was a knockoff! Beware!

Coconut Color Cream

1 review · 7.1% of its 14 · ASIN B09L8L5HJV

  • ★★★★★Apr 20, 2024Michael pennington

    Do not purchase. Could potentially be harmful! You could see lotion, color difference in the photo. One was purchased at a salon the other was purchased from here. I believe this is why the pumps don’t work because they’re being tampered with.

White 2 Bronze Coastal

1 review · 4% of its 25 · ASIN B09KJHKR15

  • ★★★★★Nov 25, 2023christy puckett

    Not real. This is not anything like the real lotion. It did nothing for me and it was just like water.

Moroccan Midnight

1 review · 3.8% of its 26 · ASIN B0979QKC22

  • ★★★★★Apr 16, 2023Helen Foreman

    Product was opened. Was disappointed that the product had already been opened. Has a shelf life once it is opened according the the package it was in.

Him Hydrate

1 review · 2.6% of its 38 · ASIN B002VHQOHI

  • ★★★★★Jul 3, 2019LA422

    This is counterfeit!. I have been using this lotion for years, purchased from a tanning salon that is an authorized retailer of the brand. I was told they are no longer selling it so I went to amazon to stock up. This lotion (the real stuff) is great because it’s not greasy at a…

Honey Gleam Cream

1 review · 2.4% of its 41 · ASIN B0BY3D19LR

  • ★★★★★Aug 3, 2024Bill Fetterman

    BUYER BEWARE, FAKE PRODUCT. Doesnt even smell like the real product you buy in a tanning salon. Smells like oil paint you get with a paint by numbers. Broke my face out ,feels heavy and doesn't soak in. have used the real product from tanning salon and if looks smells and feels…

White 2 Bronze Ink

1 review · 2.4% of its 42 · ASIN B07YQ7GYHW

  • ★★★★★Mar 5, 2022brittany

    I think it's expired. I used a sample of this product liked it and proceeded to buy it. My sample did not do this nor did my skin break out in a rash like it has from this bottle. I thought maybe it just needed a good shake to mix up but after 3 uses it has done the same thing ea…

Neon Rose

1 review · 1.4% of its 74 · ASIN B07YPZRT71

  • ★★★★★May 9, 2025Cards Fan 4

    After tan odor is terrible. Product was not sealed, which made me question the authenticity of the. Smelled ok coming out of the bottle, but it had the worst after tan odor ever. I returned product and do not recommend.

Collagenetics 2 In 1 Pro

1 review · 1.2% of its 82 · ASIN B0746PK898

  • ★★★★★Aug 1, 2019Beach tan girl

    Didn't do much for me!. Skin did not feel smooth like other reviews said. Maybe fake reviews, I bought it because I thought it would enhance my red light therapy by smoothing my skin. It does the opposite and dries my skin out. Not worth the price, definitely will not buy it again.

Prismatica

1 review · 1.1% of its 87 · ASIN B097CFVGHN

  • ★★★★★Sep 8, 2024Me

    PLEASE READ BEFORE BUYING!. ‼️If I could give 0 stars I definitely would. I’ve previously purchased this lotion MULTIPLE TIMES from my salon, but I saw it on here for a lot less so I went for it. BIG MISTAKE!! This is DEFINITELY NOT THE SAME as what I got from the salon. Huge difference! The lotion that I bought from here was very runny, smelled different and had a yellow tint to it. I contacted DC support (Because I thought maybe there was a bad batch or ??) They said absolutely not and they told me to ON…

Tattoo Stick

1 review · 0.6% of its 163 · ASIN B07HKPKWMB

  • ★★★★★May 29, 2022Nic

    Small and half full. Not what I expected. Smaller than it looks in pic. Only half full.