NEON ROSE
“Neon Rose is loved for its amazing scent and effective, visible bronzing from the first use, though some users report skin irritation.”
Safety — Flagged for Review
Recurring pattern3 independent reports of itching and skin irritation severe enough to disrupt sleep and cause physical injury (scratching to bleeding), plus 2 reports of breakouts/hives. This is a recurring pattern affecting at least 5 users and warrants formulation review — the itching/irritation may be linked to specific ingredients (rosehip oil, bakuchiol, hibiscus extracts) rather than a single isolated incident.
Negative reviews span Aug 2021–May 2025
Authenticity — Marketplace Concern
Recurring pattern4 concrete authenticity signals: (1) 4 reports of unsealed/unwrapped bottles arriving, raising tampering concerns; (2) 1 explicit report of wrong product (Color Karma sold as Neon Rose with wrong bronzer level and shimmer); (3) 4 reports of silicone balls/clumping and inconsistent product appearance not seen in salon-purchased versions; (4) 1 report of different bottle-top color than previous orders. These are marketplace-integrity issues requiring verification of FBA supplier and batch sourcing.
Negative reviews span Aug 2021–May 2025
Based on unverified customer accounts in Amazon review text, not confirmed medical or lab findings.
Avg Rating
4.2★
74 reviews
Positive
77%
Rated 4★ or 5★
Neutral
6.8%
Rated 3★
Negative
16.2%
Rated 1★ or 2★
Sentiment Score
78/100
positive
What Customers Love
Amazing scent that doesn't smell like typical burnt tanning lotion
“Even my husband and 4 year old love the smell. It isn't over powering at all but it's a nice smell that doesn't make you smell like burnt flesh after tanning”
Effective bronzing and tanning results visible after first use
“I noticed a difference in my color within the first 2 times of using this product!”
Smooth application, moisturizing, and doesn't leave greasy residue
“It smells amazing and feels so smooth and moisturizing on my skin. Doesn't leave steaks, goes on with a slight bronzing effect.”
Significantly cheaper than salon prices while maintaining same quality
“I've bought the same lotion from the tanning salon for $56.00. I ordered one off of Amazon the other day for $27.00 and it is the exact same”
Customer Feedback
AI summary. Numbers in it are the model’s estimates; counted figures are in Issue evidence below.
Silicone balls or rubber-like particles embedded in lotion that don't appear in salon-purchased versions
Product Failure“Unfortunately it leaves silicone balls everywhere. I returned it for another bottle and the same thing.”
Itching and skin irritation severe enough to cause scratching to bleeding in some users
Safety“The itch was so bad that I scratched until bleeding in certain spots. I tried this again and I never slept that night.. I was up scratching and in tears”
Bottles arriving unsealed or without proper wrapping, raising tampering concerns
Authenticity“This product came open. Nothing sealing it closed , no wrapper on it. Could have been used for all I know.”
Wrong product received — Color Karma lotion sold as Neon Rose with dark bronzer and shimmer instead of light natural bronzer
Authenticity“the lotion that was in this bottle is really Color Karma and I know because I also have that lotion. This lotion wasn't supposed to be a dark bronzer or have shimmer and it has both.”
Extreme drying and itching upon use, causing abandonment after single application
Safety“I have itched every time I tried it and dries skin out miserable!”
Color transfer and staining onto white/light-colored clothing and bedding
Product Failure“Also it does stain your clothes so if you wearing white or any light colors it will get on your clothes also gets on your bed”
Acne/breakouts on chest and arms in sensitive-skinned users
Safety“Smell was good. But made me beak out on my chest and arms.”
Issue evidence
How these are countedCounted from this product’s 74 reviews with fixed keyword rules. Click a count to read the reviews.
Complaints (1–3★ reviews)
- Skin reactions56.8%Recurring
- Fragrance complaints34.1%Recurring
- Authenticity concerns11.4%Isolated
- Streaking / orange / staining11.4%Isolated
Praise (4–5★ reviews)
- Scent customers love2635.1%Recurring
- Fast, dark results56.8%Recurring
- Cheaper than the salon56.8%Recurring
- Moisturizing / skin feel34.1%Recurring
% is the share of all 74 reviews. Recurring means 3+ reviews across 2+ different months. Listing: ASIN B07YPZRT71
Action Items by Team
Brand Protection & Authenticity (2)
- MEDIUMAdd batch/lot code and manufacturing date to the product label and a close-up photo in the listing gallery for authenticity verification.
- LOWFlag the Color Karma-sold-as-Neon-Rose report to Amazon Brand Registry for a counterfeit investigation on this ASIN.
R&D & Product Quality (1)
- HIGHRequest a lab comparison of the Amazon-sold batch vs. salon stock to investigate silicone-ball contamination reported only in Amazon units.
Supply Chain & Fulfillment (1)
- HIGHPhysically inspect a 20-30 unit sample of FBA inventory for sealing defects; escalate to fulfillment if failure rate exceeds 10%.
Customer Service (1)
- HIGHReply to 1-star itching/irritation reviews offering a full refund and asking about specific skin type and ingredient sensitivities.
Listing Content & SEO (1)
- MEDIUMAdd 'Contains natural oils; patch-test recommended' plus Rosehip/Bakuchiol/Hibiscus ingredient callouts to the listing's About This Item section.
Review Themes
Amazing scent praised, Effective tanning results, Itching/skin irritation pattern, Unsealed bottles on arrival, Silicone contamination issue, Color transfer to clothing, Cheap vs. salon pricing, Product authenticity concerns
Product Details
Key Features
• Powerful Tanning Intensifiers and Deep Natural Streak-Free/Stain-Free Bronzers • Wrinkle Fighting Bakuchiol • Rosehip Seed Oil • Hibiscus, Coconut Oil, & Strawberry Extracts • Rose Bouquet Blend™ Skin Rejuvenators • Body Fit™ Technology • BB Crème Matte Finish Formula • Provides Superior Skin Firming and Tightening Benefits • Potent Anti-Aging and Firming Ingredients • Rich Anti-oxidants • Color Correcting Blend • Sparkling Cactus Blossom Fragrance
All Reviews
All 74 Amazon reviews for this product are shown here for review · filter by star rating below
Showing 52 of 74 reviews · 5★ only — tap another rating below to switch
Great indoor tanning lotion!
Great indoor tanning lotion with natural bronzers! Lightly scented, goes on smooth, absorbs quickly without leaving a residue! I noticed a difference in my color within the first 2 times of using this product!
— sydney smith
Best tanning lotion for tanning beds
I love this tanning lotion not too tan and not pale at all and smells so amazing! I literally will not buy other lotions because this is just my favorite!
— Jasmine Elizabeth Bell
Must have for indoor tanning
Dark. Smells great. Works awesome. My favorite lotion!
— Jerilyn